Menards Fertilizer vs Scotts (2024) – Complete Guide

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Fertilizers are essential for maintaining a healthy and thriving lawn or garden. It not only provides nutrients that your plants need to thrive but also helps prevent weeds and pests.

It can be hard to choose the best product for your yard when there are so many to choose from.

In this comparison article, we will look at two popular brands of fertilizers – Menards and Scotts.

Comparison Between Menards Fertilizer and Scotts

The right choice will depend on your specific lawn care needs, budget, and personal preferences. Both brands offer a range of options that can help you achieve a healthy and vibrant lawn. The comparison table is shown below:

Menards Fertilizer

Scotts Fertilizer

Home improvement retailer Menards

Famous lawn care company Scotts

N-P-K ratio of 26-0-3

N-P-K ratio of 32-0-4

Synthetic fertilisers often contain harsh chemicals.

makes organic fertilisers.

affordable price

more expensive

Here is a clear discussion of the differences between Menards fertilizer and Scotts:

Brand Overview

Menards Fertilizer

Menards is a home improvement store offering its lawn care product line, including fertilizers. They offer organic and synthetic fertilizers for weed control and healthy growth.

Scotts Fertilizer

Scotts, a popular lawn care company, offers a variety of fertilizers for different grasses and climates. They also provide organic and synthetic options.

Nutrient Content

Food supplements, like nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K), are what fertilizers are mostly used for. Knowing which Menards or Scotts fertilizer would work best for your yard or garden is vital because they contain different nutrients.

Menards Fertilizer Nutrient Content

Menards offers a range of fertilizers, but their most popular product is the Premium Crabgrass Preventer + Lawn Food. It has an N-P-K ratio of 26-0-3, meaning it is high in nitrogen and completely lacks phosphorus. This composition makes it ideal for promoting lush green growth.

Scotts Fertilizer Nutrient Content

On the other hand, Scotts also has a variety of fertilizers, with their Turf Builder Lawn Food being a top pick among consumers.

It has an N-P-K ratio of 32-0-4, which is high in nitrogen and potassium. This composition is suitable for promoting overall plant health and root development.


Both Menards and Scotts fertilizers come with instructions for proper application. However, there are a few key differences to note.

Menards Fertilizer Application

Both Menards and Scotts fertilizers come with instructions for proper application. However, there are a few key differences to note.

Menards fertilizer requires more frequent applications than other brands due to its lower concentration of nutrients. They also offer liquid fertilizers that can be applied with a hose-end sprayer for easier application.

Scotts Fertilizer Application

Scotts fertilizers come in different forms, such as granules, spikes, and liquids, which may require other application methods.

Menards Fertilizer vs Scotts


Price is always a crucial factor for consumers, and Menards Fertilizer and Scotts Fertilizer have different pricing methods. However, it is essential to consider the value for money rather than just the initial cost.

Menards Fertilizer

 Menards fertilizers are generally more affordable compared to other brands. Their Premium Crabgrass Preventer + Lawn Food is priced at around $20 for a 12.5 lb bag.

Scotts Fertilizer 

Scotts fertilizers may be slightly more expensive, with their Turf Builder Lawn Food priced at around $25 for a 15.52 lb bag. However, they often offer promotions and discounts, making it more affordable in the long run.

Environmental Impact

It is crucial to consider the environmental impact of the fertilizers you choose. Some fertilizers may contain harmful chemicals that can harm the soil and surrounding wildlife.

Menards Fertilizer  

Most synthetic fertilizers may contain harsh chemicals that can hurt the environment. It is essential to follow application instructions carefully to avoid overuse.

Scotts Fertilizer  

Scotts has a line of organic fertilizers, such as their Organic Choice Lawn Food that are safer for the environment. However, they also offer synthetic options like their Turf Builder Lawn Food.

User Reviews

A great way to gain insight into the effectiveness of a fertilizer is by reading user reviews. Menards and Scotts have a loyal customer base and receive positive reviews for their fertilizers.

However, some users have reported issues with certain products from both brands. It is essential to read multiple reviews and consider the majority opinion before choosing.


What is the difference between Menards fertilizer and Scotts fertilizer?

Scotts is a popular brand, while Menards fertilizer is a private label offered at Menards stores.

Which fertilizer is better for my lawn?

Menards and Scotts offer a range of fertilizers for different lawn care needs. Before choosing a fertilizer, examine your lawn type, nutrients, and other needs.

Are Menards fertilizers as effective as Scotts fertilizers?

Menards and Scotts sell good fertilizers. However, their efficacy depends on the type and application. It’s important to read the labels and choose the right fertilizer for your lawn’s needs.

Is one brand more affordable than the other?

Pricing can vary depending on the specific product and the retailer. It’s best to compare prices and consider any promotions or discounts available at the time of purchase.

an I use Menards fertilizer in my garden?

Menards offers a range of fertilizers for different purposes, including those suitable for gardens. Choosing the right fertilizer for your gardening needs is important and following the application instructions accordingly.


In conclusion, Menards and Scotts offer high-quality fertilizers with different nutrient compositions, pricing, user reviews, effectiveness, and availability. Ultimately, the best fertilizer for you will depend on your specific lawn and garden needs. It is recommended to assess these factors and do thorough research before deciding. We hope this comparison helped you choose the best fertilizer for healthy plant growth and a beautiful landscape. So, next time you are at the store, consider all these factors before purchasing a fertilizer from either Menards or Scotts.

Leave a Comment